Get fit games, they do nothing

by Ben Salter Featured 10 Comments 30 Votes 4009 Views 28/02/2012 Back to News

Research is back to ruin the fun once again, this time claiming to somewhat surprisingly find that active "get fit" style games don't make kids more active.

Researchers in Houston gave two groups of kids who didn't already own a Wii Nintendo's motion-controlled console.

The first group played active games like Wii Fit, while the second group played more traditional inactive games like Super Mario Galaxy.

The kids wore accelerometers for 13 weeks and had data taken at weeks one, six, seven and 12.

The results found that those in the active game group averaged 25 to 28 minutes of moderate or vigorous physical activity each day, compared to 26 to 29 minutes in the inactive group, reports Reuters.

"Frankly we were shocked by the complete lack of difference," said researcher Tom Baranowski.

However, the same might not ring true for adults. Another study has found it doesn't matter how much time a child spends sitting down, as long as they get their recommended 30-60 minutes of exercise per day, whereas more physical activity is beneficial to adults.

Link to us http://ds.mmgn.com/News/Get-fit-games-they-do-nothing
Vote for this article Log in with Facebook

Get fit games, they do nothing Comments

Leave a comment Log in with Facebook
Well duh! [Facepalm]
Seems like a fairly narrow study. Simply relying on tracking acceleration and movement doesn't necessarily accurately indicate the effectiveness or quality of the exercise being done. Some of those Wii Fit exercises rely on holding a position to build strength, rather than repeated movements, and therefore wouldn't show up in their results. The game exercises could also be providing more efficient exercises than what the other group were doing.

Makra said: Seems like a fairly narrow study. Simply relying on tracking acceleration and movement doesn't necessarily accurately indicate the effectiveness or quality of the exercise being done. Some of those Wii Fit exercises rely on holding a position to build strength, rather than repeated movements, and therefore wouldn't show up in their results. The game exercises could also be providing more efficient exercises than what the other group were doing.



I thought the same thing.

I think these fit programs provide pretty good incentive. My mum uses hers and still goes to the gym. She uses it for Yoga and just mini-games. She loves it.
Eat less, move more
If you are moving you burn some calories so playing something like Wii Fit has to do something.
Wii Fit Games DO make you lose weight !
There's a built in graph and it proves it !

I read once that twiddling your thumbs uses the same calories as walking.....so the results aren't a surprise to me.

PS3sR2Dear said:
I read once that twiddling your thumbs uses the same calories as walking.....so the results aren't a surprise to me.



Sorry but that is so wrong. Just think about the muscle movement involved in each exercise and the amount of energy used to process the movement. If this was the case gamers would be the 2nd fittest type of person (2nd to those who do propper exercise/workout)
Used-Calories does not Equal 'Cardio Vascular Fitness'.
Walking for humans is a very efficient form of exercise, unless you walk-off-the CALORIES, eaten, you will not lose weight.
And as for twiddling, you'll get stronger thumbs for sure lol

PS3sR2Dear said:
I read once that twiddling your thumbs uses the same calories as walking.....so the results aren't a surprise to me.



Who said that, Bobby Kotick (activision blizzard prez) :P

anyways I'm sure some of these games would do some sort of work out - I've put up a sweat on dance central [Shifty] but it's not something I rely on.

PS3sR2Dear said: Wii Fit Games DO make you lose weight !
There's a built in graph and it proves it !
I read once that twiddling your thumbs uses the same calories as walking.....so the results aren't a surprise to me.


That's gotta be wrong. Someone who walks for 4 hours a day would not be fat if they had a normal metabolism. Someone who played games for 4 hours a day couldn't expect the same, assuming both had the same diet.

Post a comment

Leave a comment Log in with Facebook

Recently Read

Featured 3DS Content

GOTY 2015: Best Game Of 2015

GOTY 2015: Best Game Of 2015

22/12/2015 Polls 17 13
Friendly Fire Show 117: It's not goodbye, it's Halo!

Friendly Fire Show 117: It's not goodbye, it's Halo!

Podcast 5 days Articles 2 3
MMGN.com in 2016 - Why there is no new content

MMGN.com in 2016 - Why there is no new content

MMGN 6 days News 5 14
Special edition 2DS Pokémon bundles revealed

Special edition 2DS Pokémon bundles revealed

Gryllis 13/01 News 14 13
MMGN Game Of The Year 2015 Results: You decided
Tano 07/01 News 23 12
Nintendo 3DS Exclusives for 2016

Nintendo 3DS Exclusives for 2016

Gryllis 07/01 Articles 1 6
MMGN GOTY 2015 Voting closes Jan 7

MMGN GOTY 2015 Voting closes Jan 7

GOTY 05/01 News 3 7
Year in review: The stories that mattered in 2015

Year in review: The stories that mattered in 2015

Tano 31/12 Articles 1 3
Year in review: Our favourite games of 2015

Year in review: Our favourite games of 2015

MMGNTeam 30/12 Articles 3 6

Community Content

#PAXAUS Melbourne Tourist Guide

#PAXAUS Melbourne Tourist Guide

29/10/2015 Blog 11 0

MMGN Updates

Status
Updating..
Username

kangle4, MyFragian commented on Special edition 2DS Pokémon Red, Blue and Yellow bundles revealed

kangle4 2 days ago
Username

talka is now Level 4!

talka 3 days ago
Username

commented on MMGN.com in 2016 - Why there is no new content

Booth 3 days ago
Username

commented on GOTY 2015: Best Game Of 2015

jamesbradl 4 days ago
Username

commented on MMGN.com in 2016 - Why there is no new content

maxiboy 5 days ago
Username

Dave-in-lk is now Level 7!

Dave-in-lk 6 days ago
Username

KezDaMuss is now Level 15!

KezDaMuss 30/01/2016
Username

heavenly10 is now Level 2!

heavenly10 30/01/2016