Pokémon X & Y review

by Jayden Williams Featured

25 Comments 32 Votes 36371 Views 18/10/2013 Back to Reviews

Pokémon X and Pokémon Y are a brand new beginning for the franchise. A bold step into a brighter, better future that bring with them a range of long-sought after game features including, but not limited to, completely overhauled visuals and deeply integrated online functionality.

There’s a lot of new ground broken in these sixth generation Pokémon games, that much is certain, but many of the core elements that make up any Pokémon game still remain. You still pick either a Grass/Fire/Water starter, you do battle with a themed villainous group of criminals, and you still collect eight Gym badges and go on to defeat the Elite Four. These, and many other series staples, all make up the successful pocket monster formula that Game Freak has been selling for 17 years. It would be silly to mess with it now.


The thing is though, Game Freak don’t have to. Pokémon X and Pokémon Y successfully avoid anything that’s come before from feeling stale, with numerous changes and improvements making the overall experience appear fresh and invigorating.

Where they excel is making the tried and true Pokémon formula feel fresh, new and wholly invigorated. After 17 years, that’s something that shouldn’t be taken lightly.

From the outset you’ll notice exactly how much impact these changes actually have. The most noticeable being the overhauled visuals; gone are the sprites of the last 16 years, replaced with full 3D character models. The much lauded character customisation hits you square in the face, allowing you to select different hair and skin colour — with more robust customisation options available later in the game.

The all-new Kalos region is a beautiful place to explore, and we’re lucky it’s the first to be realised with this new engine. Filled with bountiful fields of flowers and wonderfully varied terrain, it's — something that’s cemented further with the addition of Pokémon riding. When it comes to battling, the new engine displays all 718 Pokémon with their own individual animations. Couple this with the addition of a dynamic camera, and what we get are Pokémon battles that feel a lot more invigorating and a lot less sterile than ever before.

It’s not all about the cosmetic facelift the series has received, with a whole host of new under-the-hood features, improvements and tweaks to the successful formula being introduced over the course of the game, each one making you perk up to say something along the lines: "well I’m glad they did that!" In respect to the core gameplay, two of the most prominent new features are Super-Training and Pokémon-Aime.

The former enables you to engage in mini-games with your Pokémon, allowing you to boost their proficiency in a particular stat. Think of it as something like IV/EV training, only a lot more transparent. Pokémon-Amie, on the other hand, sees you rubbing your Pokémon’s stomach, feeding it treats or playing mini-games; all in a bid to raise its affections towards you. Raise them enough and you’ll begin to notice added bonuses like extra experience and a higher chance to dodge attack in battle


Both are surprisingly deep features, and while it’s certainly recommended you invest time in both, the game won’t punish you if you’d prefer to just stick with the core experience. Think of them both as extra candy toppings atop the Pokémon sundae Game Freak has whipped up. Only, neither will actually rot your teeth.

Speaking of that juicy, core Pokémon experience, it’s largely the same, but with one glaring exception: the Fairy type. While the addition of Sky Battles and Horde Encounters attempt to add an extra layer of depth to battling, neither radically change how we fundamentally engage with it. I take issue with Sky Battles/Horde Encounters, mainly due to them feeling gimmicky, underused and, especially in the case of the latter, clunky. I see where Game Freak was coming from, but both were resources better utilised elsewhere.

Fairy type, on the other hand, is brilliant. Its introduction has forever changed the type matchup charts, forcing veteran and casual players alike to once again second guess their strategies, attack plans and team lineups. A new type is definitely what Pokémon needed to shake things up a little; however I remain hopeful Game Freak doesn’t go overboard and introduce another new type in a year or two.

What I feel Pokémon didn’t need were Mega Evolutions. While somewhat pivotal to the game’s rather weak storyline, and undoubtedly useful in making badass Pokémon in looking more badass, its function is almost entirely pointless. The theory behind it is certain pocket monsters transcend to a temporary higher evolved state, wherein its stats are energised and, in the case of some species, its typing being altered. The crux of my issues with Mega Evolution stems from a question of balance; how can we be assured this will cause a rash of superpowered Pokémon in competitive battling?


Where Pokémon X and Pokémon Y truly excel, however, is in the new Player Search System — making all other new features pale in comparison. Accessible at any time from the touchscreen, you can instantly connect with other players from all around the world — not to mention those registered as friends. Battle, trade, voice chat, give/receive O-Powers (limited time bonuses)... there’s a whole lot the PSS can do, and it’s X/Y’s biggest leap when it comes to innovative.

Aside from connecting with a friend, or random passerby, to trade or battle, you’re able to take part in new features, such as Wonder Trade. Nothing more than a simple game of chance, Wonder Trade has trainers engage in a Pokémon trade with another randomly selected player. Neither of you know what you’ll get, making it equally incredibly exciting and horribly addictive. Perhaps more than anything, features like Wonder Trade, not to mention the rest of the PSS suite, help sell X/Y’s complete sense of social togetherness this series has always been about — and that’s something special.

The Final Verdict

I could write volumes on how, and why, Pokémon X and Pokémon Y are the best Pokémon games since generation two, but all you really need to do is play one of them for yourself. As a collective, they’re by no means perfect. The invent of 3D visuals reveals issues concerning visual lag and slowdown that need to be addressed in the future, while a clear justification of Mega Evolutions (outside of them just looking cool) is most certainly needed. Where they excel, however, is making the tried and true Pokémon formula feel fresh, new and wholly invigorated. After 17 years, that’s something that shouldn’t be taken lightly.

Pokémon X and Y

Got Right
  • + Player Search System is an online revolution
  • + 3D Pokémon models are amazing
  • + Refreshes the tried & true Pokémon formula
  • + Character customisation
Got Wrong
  • - Mega Evolutions raises questions of balance
  • - Noticeable visual lag & slowdown
Platform: DS
Developer: Game Freak
Similar to: Pokémon Black and White 2.
 
Vote for this article Log in with Facebook

More Info on Pokémon X and Y

Pokemon x and y Pokemon x & y My Pokemon 3DS XLs Pokemon X Kero 2DS bundles include Pokemon Pokemon Trainer

Pokémon X & Y review Comments

Leave a comment Log in with Facebook
Tano
+
Y U NO GIVE IT 10?

Pokémon X & Y review

Tano said: Y U NO GIVE IT 10?


No game is perfect [MOG]

Jayden27 said:

Tano said: Y U NO GIVE IT 10?


No game is perfect


10 Doesn't mean perfect, but Pokemon doesn't quite deserve one.
good read
At first I was a bit surprised by the new EXP system that gives all your team EXP, not just the one battling. But it's saving quite a bit of time.

Good change.
Doesnt deserve a 10 YET...
But 9.5 is definately a good rating.

Gryllis said: At first I was a bit surprised by the new EXP system that gives all your team EXP, not just the one battling. But it's saving quite a bit of time.
Good change.


I turned it off because I was getting way overleveled, but now I'm cycling through 12 Pokemon with it on and staying the right level [MOG]

Gryllis said: At first I was a bit surprised by the new EXP system that gives all your team EXP, not just the one battling. But it's saving quite a bit of time.
Good change.


I know some people see it as cheating and disable it, but I always end up with 2 strong pokemon and the rest useless so I love it :P

Also takes some grind out.
Lo33
+
Good read :D
Good read, but I don't believe Mega Evolutions bring up balance concerns, based on the fact that you can't use them in online battles unless your opponent is using one too.

However, as far as balance throughout the storyline goes, it's been made quite easy (and less grindy) this time around, which I'm not sure how I feel about.

In regards to the comments made regarding sky battles and hordes, I think you're both right and wrong.. Horde battles do feel a bit clunky, but they emulate exactly what is seen in the anime.. I can thinking of many moments from the first few seasons that are appropriate for hoard moments, eg, a Spearow horde would be perfect, just as Ash was overrun by Spearows in the TV show.

To me they definitely add a bit of Pokemon vibe to fans of the show.

As for sky battles, they're awesome! Again, quite relevant to the anime. I can see it evolving into underwater battles, as an addition. Like when Ash verses Misty in the TV show, where an underwater Pokemon is more or less required for the battle.

Definitely adds incentive to go catch them all.

Unfortunately sky battles weren't found all that often throughout X/Y.. But I believe their inclusion here could definitely lead to something bigger that more closely resembles the anime, which I think is what we're all after.

Anyway, that's just nitpicking :P Your review is spot on. Good read :)
Josh
+

Jayden27 said:

Tano said: Y U NO GIVE IT 10?


No game is perfect



This deserves a 9.8 for sure. :P

Harry said: Good read, but I don't believe Mega Evolutions bring up balance concerns, based on the fact that you can't use them in online battles unless your opponent is using one too.
However, as far as balance throughout the storyline goes, it's been made quite easy (and less grindy) this time around, which I'm not sure how I feel about.
In regards to the comments made regarding sky battles and hordes, I think you're both right and wrong.. Horde battles do feel a bit clunky, but they emulate exactly what is seen in the anime.. I can thinking of many moments from the first few seasons that are appropriate for hoard moments, eg, a Spearow horde would be perfect, just as Ash was overrun by Spearows in the TV show.
To me they definitely add a bit of Pokemon vibe to fans of the show.
As for sky battles, they're awesome! Again, quite relevant to the anime. I can see it evolving into underwater battles, as an addition. Like when Ash verses Misty in the TV show, where an underwater Pokemon is more or less required for the battle.
Definitely adds incentive to go catch them all.
Unfortunately sky battles weren't found all that often throughout X/Y.. But I believe their inclusion here could definitely lead to something bigger that more closely resembles the anime, which I think is what we're all after.
Anyway, that's just nitpicking Your review is spot on. Good read


I whole-heartily agree with you on all fronts, but I was looking at these from a design perspective, and I couldn't see how they fit in...

I respect why they're there, but I don't think they bring anything to the actual gameplay. In saying that, I like how they invoke a more "realistic" approach to battles, because yeah I think you'd encounter hordes of 'mons and battle in the sky.

Both are cool, and I'd like to see underwater battles (seems like an organic choice!) as well.

But seriously, thanks for reading and commenting :)
you guys know a review is someones opinion it doesn't have to match yours

Tj866 said: you guys know a review is someones opinion it doesn't have to match yours


Nobody is complaining, just discussing :)

@Jayden27 - always a pleasure ;) Here's hoping the next Pokemon game takes these and turns them into something meaningful :D

Josh said:

Jayden27 said:

Tano said: Y U NO GIVE IT 10?


No game is perfect



Hyrule field is too empty.
Ocarina of Time is shit. If you had said Wind Waker, maybe.
ALTTP master race

iamtom said: Ocarina of Time is shit. If you had said Wind Waker, maybe.



You'll live to rue the day you said that
HORY SHET GUIZ STAY ON TOPIC [Rage]

Blob said: Hyrule field is too empty.

T.T I want a 2DS now :(

Josh said:

Jayden27 said:

Tano said: Y U NO GIVE IT 10?


No game is perfect



that game isn't perfect either.

Luke1993 said:

Josh said:

Jayden27 said:

Tano said: Y U NO GIVE IT 10?


No game is perfect



that game isn't perfect either.



Tano said:

Luke1993 said:

Josh said:

Jayden27 said:

Tano said: Y U NO GIVE IT 10?


No game is perfect



that game isn't perfect either.



I still stand by my statement; no game is perfect [MOG] [MOG]
considering Pokemon has one of the worst stories I have ever seen in an rpg game. That alone is why it can never get a 10/10.

Post a comment

Leave a comment Log in with Facebook
  • Pokemon x and y
  • Pokemon x & y
  • My Pokemon 3DS XLs
  • Pokemon X Kero
  • 2DS bundles include Pokemon
  • Pokemon Trainer
  • Pokémon X and YPokémon X and Y Video
  • Pokémon X and YPokémon X and Y Video

Recently Read

Featured 3DS Content

Favourite 2014 game so far?

Favourite 2014 game so far?

19/06/2014 Polls 23 39
Friendly Fire Show 70: The Amazing Dergerpopa

Friendly Fire Show 70: The Amazing Dergerpopa

Podcast 1 day Articles 0 3
New 3DS & New 3DS XL playable at PAX Australia
Gryllis 1 day News 1 8
Pokémon Omega Ruby/Alpha Sapphire demo coming

Pokémon Omega Ruby/Alpha Sapphire demo coming

Gryllis 4 days News 5 8
Transparent red/blue 2DS bundles coming in Dec

Transparent red/blue 2DS bundles coming in Dec

Gryllis 4 days News 6 11
Nintendo Direct Australia is here with fresh local news

Nintendo Direct Australia is here with fresh local news

Tano 6 days News 3 7
New 3DS, XL launching in Australia in November

New 3DS, XL launching in Australia in November

Gryllis 6 days News 11 11
Preview: Watch what's new in Skylanders Trap Team

Preview: Watch what's new in Skylanders Trap Team

RSOP 22/09 Articles 2 4
Friendly Fire Show 69: Fangin' Destiny

Friendly Fire Show 69: Fangin' Destiny

Podcast 22/09 Articles 0 3

Community Content

ZiNG Pop Culture Stores open around Australia

ZiNG Pop Culture Stores open around Australia

Leasha 18/09 News 13 11
Awesome Gaming Stuff Of Tomorrow, Today! Vol. 3

Awesome Gaming Stuff Of Tomorrow, Today! Vol. 3

02/09/2014 Blog 10 0

MMGN Updates

Status
Updating..
Username

Flyverson got inFAMOUS: First Light, Destiny

Flyverson 6 hours ago
Username

Lo33 got Forza Horizon 2, Watch Dogs, Destiny

Lo33 8 hours ago
Username

commented on Blak's Massive Figurine Collection

Mirage 9 hours ago
Username

Nibs101 is selling - Mega Drive Game : Mazin Wars

Nibs101 9 hours ago
Username

Nibs101 is selling - Mega Drive Games : Aladdin & Alien Storm

Nibs101 9 hours ago
Username

Nibs101 is selling - Mega Drive Games : Wonder Boy in Monster Land & Kid Chameleon

Nibs101 9 hours ago
Username

Nibs101 is selling - Mega Drive Games : Sonic 2 & Super Monaco GP

Nibs101 9 hours ago